Shoppable gift guide

Best Anal Toys of 2026: 12 Hand-Picked Gifts for a Trip Down the Chimney

Plugs, beads and prostate massagers for every level, from first-timer plug sets to app-controlled luxury. Hand-picked for a very naughty Christmas.

November 3, 2026 ยท 5 min read ยท By Naughty Nick

The One Anal Plug Set by The One
Adam & Eve Pink Gem Anal Plug Set by Adam & Eve
ROMP Bass Vibrating Anal Plug by ROMP
PinkCherry It's A Gem Vibrating Butt Plug by PinkCherry

Santa goes down the chimney every Christmas Eve, and frankly, he's onto something. Anal play is one of the most-searched, least-talked-about corners of the Naughty List: the anus is packed with nerve endings, and for anyone with a prostate, the P-spot sits just a couple of inches inside. Get the right toy, plenty of lube and a little patience, and the back door becomes everyone's favorite entrance.

We hand-picked the best anal toys in Down the Chimney, from sparkly first-timer plug sets to app-controlled prostate massagers, plus the two extras every butt-stuff gift needs. Save any pick to your Naughty List and share one live link, so you can drop hints without saying a word.

Best anal toys for beginners: start small, size up

The golden rule of anal: start smaller than you think, go slow, and use more lube than seems reasonable. A graduated set lets you (or your giftee) work up at your own pace, and it makes a very cheeky stocking stuffer.

The One Anal Plug Set is our top pick for first-timers: three silicone plugs in small, medium and large, each with a tapered tip and a flared base, and it's waterproof, so it's happy in the shower too.

If they like a little bling, the Adam & Eve Pink Gem set packs three graduated aluminum plugs with pink gem bases. Metal has a satisfying weight and is great for temperature play: warm it in your hands first, or chill it for a gasp.

Best vibrating butt plugs: a little buzz in the back

Once a plain plug feels easy, add vibration. A buzzing plug turns "just wearing it" into a full-body hum, and it pairs beautifully with a wand or a partner.

The ROMP Bass is a beginner-friendly silicone plug with deep, rumbly vibration (the bassy kind, not the buzzy kind), and it's waterproof and rechargeable. Big feelings, small price.

PinkCherry's It's A Gem plug is platinum silicone with a jeweled base that doubles as the control panel. The Jackpot is a curved silicone probe with a swollen tip and 12 vibration patterns, angled for the G-spot or P-spot depending on who's unwrapping it.

Best anal beads: the slow, luxe option

Beads are the "one more, one more" toy: graduated sizes mean every bead is a tiny milestone.

LELO's SORAYA Beads are body-safe silicone with graduated sizing and LELO's Bow-Motion technology, designed for A-spot or P-spot play. They're the splurge pick for someone who already knows they like a slow build.

Best prostate massagers: gifts for Mr. Claus

For anyone with a prostate, this is where anal toys really earn their place under the tree. A good prostate massager curves toward the P-spot inside and often has a second arm or motor for the perineum (the sensitive stretch between the balls and the anus) on the outside.

The LELO LOKI Wave 2 has a beckoning "come-hither" Wave motion inside and a second motor for the perineum: first-class travel down the chimney.

The We-Vibe Vector+ has an adjustable outer arm for the perineum plus remote and app control, so a partner can hold the reins. LELO's HUGO 2 is the flagship: two motors, one in the tip and one in the base, with app control. Both are waterproof. Shopping for him more broadly? See our gifts for Mr. Claus.

Best app-controlled butt plug for couples

The Je Joue Nuo V2 is a velvety silicone plug with two independent motors, app control and a comfortable T-bar base. Hand your partner the phone and let them be in charge of the holiday cheer. It's our pick for experienced players who want a plug they can wear through a whole evening of mistletoe.

Don't forget the lube (and the cleanup)

The anus doesn't make its own lubrication, so lube isn't optional: it's the whole gift. Pick a thick, water-based formula, which is safe with every silicone toy on this list. Then keep things fresh with a dedicated toy cleaner before and after.

Adam & Eve Forbidden is a thick, cushiony water-based gel made for anal play, with a stay-put texture. Lovehoney Fresh is a big bottle of water-based toy cleaner that works on silicone, TPE and cyberskin. For more slippery options, browse the Grease the Sleigh aisle.

Anal toy gift FAQ

What's the best anal toy for a total beginner? A graduated silicone plug set, like The One Anal Plug Set. Start with the smallest size, use plenty of water-based lube, and only move up when the last size feels easy. Always pick toys made for anal, with a flared or T-bar base.

Can I use silicone lube with silicone anal toys? Stick to water-based lube with silicone toys. Silicone lube can damage some silicone toys' surface over time. Forbidden is water-based and made for anal, so it's a safe pairing with everything here.

Is an anal toy a weird Christmas gift? Only if it's a surprise to someone who's never mentioned it. If you've talked about it, it's a thoughtful, very personal gift. Not sure? Build a Naughty List together with "Make it ours," and let them add what they're curious about.

Why does an anal toy need a flared base? The body can draw a smooth toy inward, and a flared base or loop stops that. Never use a toy for anal play without one.

How do you clean an anal toy? Wash it with warm water and mild soap or toy cleaner after every use, then dry it fully. Wash it again, or use a fresh condom, before it goes anywhere else.

What's the difference between a butt plug and a prostate massager? A plug stays in place for a feeling of fullness. A prostate massager is curved to press toward the prostate and often vibrates.

Ready to go down the chimney?

Browse everything in Down the Chimney, grab a plug set from the Stocking Stuffer Market, or let Cocoa match you in the Gift Finder. Save your favorites to your Naughty List and share one live link with someone nice.

Prices and stock change often. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.

Checked twice

Santa's cheat sheet

All 12 picks from this guide, side by side. Tap a heart to add one, or take the whole sleigh.

The naughty-or-nice meter: the fuller the stripes, the naughtier the gift. It's a spice level, not a score.

GiftHow naughtyPriceWhy it should make your listAdd to my list
The OneThe One Anal Plug Set
$25.95Small, medium, large. Work your way up the list.
Adam & EveAdam & Eve Pink Gem Anal Plug Set
$17.99Three sparkly sizes for a first trip down the chimney.
ROMPROMP Bass Vibrating Anal Plug
$39.99A little bass line for the back door.
PinkCherryPinkCherry It's A Gem Vibrating Butt Plug
$49.90A jeweled plug that buzzes. Bling for the back chimney.
PinkCherryPinkCherry Jackpot Vibrating Pleasure Probe
$49.90A vibrating probe that hits the jackpot.
LELOSORAYA Beads
$229.95Vibrating beads for a luxe trip down the chimney.
LELOLOKI Wave 2
$160.30A beckoning prostate massager. Down the chimney, first class.
We-VibeWe-Vibe Vector+
$139.00A remote, an app and a very good time for him.
LELOHUGO 2
$177.25Two motors, one app, zero guesswork.
Je JoueJe Joue Nuo V2 Plug
$156.00Two motors, one app, zero guesswork down the chimney.
Adam & EveAdam & Eve Forbidden Anal Lubricant (4 oz)
$17.99 $9.00with code 50PLUSThicker, slicker, made for trips down the chimney.
LovehoneyLovehoney Fresh Toy Cleaner 8.5 oz
$13.99Before, after, and before again.

Send this guide to someone who should be shopping for you.

More from the workshop

Related guides

Still deciding?

Let the elves narrow the list without judging the assignment.

Try the Gift Finder

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Adults 18+ only.